Roth Conversion Calculator
See what moving money from a traditional IRA or 401(k) into a Roth actually costs — and saves — over your whole retirement, one bracket-filling year at a time.
A Roth conversion moves money out of your tax-deferred accounts and into a Roth, paying income tax on the amount now so it — and everything it earns afterward — grows and comes out tax-free. Done in the right years and in the right size, a series of conversions can shrink a lifetime tax bill by tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars. Done blindly, it can waste the low-tax years you'll never get back, or spill into a higher bracket and cost more than it saves. The difference is entirely a question of how much to convert and when — which is exactly what a calculator should answer for your own numbers, not a rule of thumb.
What a conversion ladder actually does
The classic move is a conversion ladder: in a low-income year — after you stop working, between jobs, on a sabbatical, or any year before Social Security and required minimum distributions arrive — you convert just enough to fill up a target tax bracket, say to the top of the 12% or 22% band, without tipping into the next one. Each rung is a year; each rung shifts a slice of tax-deferred money into the Roth at a rate you chose deliberately. Fill those years and you arrive at 73 with a smaller traditional balance, smaller RMDs, and a large tax-free Roth you never have to touch.
Why RMDs are the whole reason to bother
Left alone, a large traditional IRA doesn't stay quiet. At 73 the IRS forces required minimum distributions — a rising percentage of the balance every year, taxed as ordinary income whether you need the money or not. For a healthy saver those forced withdrawals can push income high enough to tax more of your Social Security, trigger IRMAA surcharges on Medicare Parts B and D, and drag you into a bracket you spent your career avoiding. Converting earlier, on your terms, drains the traditional balance before the government starts draining it for you. The calculator below models that RMD pressure explicitly, so you can see the surcharge cliffs you're steering around — not just the headline tax rate.
What "optimal" means here
retireclarity's optimizer doesn't just apply a bracket rule — it searches conversion schedules and returns a near-optimal one, while respecting tax brackets, the two-year IRMAA lookback, the ACA subsidy cliff, and the RMDs still waiting downstream. What it maximizes is the money you keep after every tax is paid — and you get it as a year-by-year schedule, with the lifetime tax saved shown alongside, so the recommendation is a number you can inspect, not a black box you have to trust.
Want the deeper background first? Read how a Roth conversion ladder works, the mechanics behind this calculator, and real conversion strategies. Or jump straight to the full Roth conversion optimizer.
The calculator below is already running a sample household. Load it into the full planner and swap in your own accounts, spending, and ages.
Try it with this sampleRoth Conversion Optimizer
Money you keep
+$72K
more after tax at 95 than converting nothing
Tax now
$22K
all-in, in your conversion years
Converting $164K between 47 and 74 costs $17K in tax now, and moves that money somewhere it — and everything it earns from here — is never taxed again. It empties your tax-deferred balance by 95.
How much to convert
The full gain, for the whole tax bill.
How this is calculatedHide details
Why “Tax now” is bigger than the tax on the conversions — that number is only the income tax on the conversions themselves: what shows up on your tax returns, and what the yearly schedule adds up to. This figure also counts everything a conversion sets off in the same year — higher Medicare premiums, extra investment tax, lost health-insurance subsidies. The money you keep has already paid all of those, so the cost side includes them too.
What this rests on — Converting more prepays more tax on the strength of today’s assumptions.
What you keep
Roth conversions shift money out of tax-deferred and into Roth. RMDs begin — 75. Tax-deferred depletes at 95. All balances are in today’s dollars.
Why this works
Tax per year
You pay more tax in the conversion years and less afterwards. Everything is in today’s dollars.
IRMAA: clear every year
Roth Conversion Schedule
| Age | Conversion | Why | Tax now | Tax laterThe tax these dollars draw in RMD years if left in the IRA — today’s dollars, estimated. | Saves | ACA subsidy | ACA net |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 47 | $1.0K | Subsidy shrinksWhy not more this year: From here, each extra dollar converted shrinks this year’s $8.3K health-insurance subsidy. | $0Tax on this conversion: . Total $0. | $120 | $120Saves prices this year’s tax-rate difference alone. Whole plan, this conversion kept vs dropped: final after-tax estate $71 higher in today’s dollars. | $8.3K | $2.2K |
| 48 | $4.4K | Subsidy lostWhy not more this year: Converted up to the point where one more dollar would cost this year’s $4.8K health-insurance subsidy. | $0Tax on this conversion: . Total $0. | $524 | $524Saves prices this year’s tax-rate difference alone. Whole plan, this conversion kept vs dropped: final after-tax estate $4,527 higher in today’s dollars. | $4.8K | $5.9K |
| 49 | $4.7K | Subsidy lostWhy not more this year: Converted up to the point where one more dollar would cost this year’s $4.8K health-insurance subsidy. | $0Tax on this conversion: . Total $0. | $566 | $566Saves prices this year’s tax-rate difference alone. Whole plan, this conversion kept vs dropped: final after-tax estate $4,691 higher in today’s dollars. | $4.8K | $6.1K |
| 50 | $8.8K | Subsidy lostWhy not more this year: Converted up to the point where one more dollar would cost this year’s $4.8K health-insurance subsidy. | $0Tax on this conversion: . Total $0. | $1.1K | $1.1KSaves prices this year’s tax-rate difference alone. Whole plan, this conversion kept vs dropped: final after-tax estate $9,641 higher in today’s dollars. | $4.8K | $6.3K |
| 51 | $6.7K | Subsidy lostWhy not more this year: Converted up to the point where one more dollar would cost this year’s $5.5K health-insurance subsidy. | $0Tax on this conversion: . Total $0. | $800 | $800Saves prices this year’s tax-rate difference alone. Whole plan, this conversion kept vs dropped: final after-tax estate $6,468 higher in today’s dollars. | $5.5K | $6.3K |
| 52 | $5.2K | Subsidy lostWhy not more this year: Converted up to the point where one more dollar would cost this year’s $6.3K health-insurance subsidy. | $0Tax on this conversion: . Total $0. | $621 | $621Saves prices this year’s tax-rate difference alone. Whole plan, this conversion kept vs dropped: final after-tax estate $4,373 higher in today’s dollars. | $6.3K | $6.3K |
| 53 | $3.5K | Subsidy lostWhy not more this year: Converted up to the point where one more dollar would cost this year’s $7.1K health-insurance subsidy. | $0Tax on this conversion: . Total $0. | $421 | $421Saves prices this year’s tax-rate difference alone. Whole plan, this conversion kept vs dropped: final after-tax estate $2,316 higher in today’s dollars. | $7.1K | $6.3K |
| 54 | Not recommended | Not enough cashWhy this amount: Skipped — converting more would leave you about $3.2K short of the cash to pay the tax at 54. | $0 | $14.3K | |||
| 55 | Not recommended | Not enough cashWhy this amount: Skipped — converting more would leave you about $1.3K short of the cash to pay the tax at 55. | $0 | $15.3K | |||
| 56 | Not recommended | Not enough cashWhy this amount: Skipped — converting more would leave you about $1.3K short of the cash to pay the tax at 56. | $0 | $16.3K | |||
| 57 | Not recommended | Not enough cashWhy this amount: Skipped — converting more would leave you about $1.2K short of the cash to pay the tax at 57. | $0 | $17.3K | |||
| 58 | Not recommended | Not enough cashWhy this amount: Skipped — converting more would leave you about $1.2K short of the cash to pay the tax at 58. | $0 | $18.5K | |||
| 59 | Not recommended | Optimizer skipped itWhy this amount: Skipped — converting more this year would cost more than it gains. | $0 | $19.2K | |||
| 60 | Not recommended | Optimizer skipped itWhy this amount: Skipped — converting more this year would cost more than it gains. | $0 | $20.4K | |||
| 61 | Not recommended | Optimizer skipped itWhy this amount: Skipped — converting more this year would cost more than it gains. | $0 | $21.6K | |||
| 62 | Not recommended | Optimizer skipped itWhy this amount: Skipped — converting more this year would cost more than it gains. | $0 | $22.5K | |||
| 63 | Not recommended | Optimizer skipped itWhy this amount: Skipped — converting more this year would cost more than it gains. | $0 | $23.6K | |||
| 64 | Not recommended | Optimizer skipped itWhy this amount: Skipped — converting more this year would cost more than it gains. | $0 | $24.4K | |||
| 65 | $6.8K | Same tax laterWhy not more this year: Costs about the same tax now as waiting — this conversion is here to shrink future RMDs and move money into tax-free growth, not to save tax this year. | $878Tax on this conversion: Federal (ordinary) $878, Federal capital gains $0. Total $878. | $811 | −$67Saves prices this year’s tax-rate difference alone. Whole plan, this conversion kept vs dropped: final after-tax estate $2,653 higher in today’s dollars. | — | — |
| 66 | $6.4K | Same tax laterWhy not more this year: Costs about the same tax now as waiting — this conversion is here to shrink future RMDs and move money into tax-free growth, not to save tax this year. | $805Tax on this conversion: Federal (ordinary) $805, Federal capital gains $0. Total $805. | $766 | −$39Saves prices this year’s tax-rate difference alone. Whole plan, this conversion kept vs dropped: final after-tax estate $2,333 higher in today’s dollars. | — | — |
| 67 | $6.1K | Same tax laterWhy not more this year: Costs about the same tax now as waiting — this conversion is here to shrink future RMDs and move money into tax-free growth, not to save tax this year. | $751Tax on this conversion: Federal (ordinary) $751, Federal capital gains $0. Total $751. | $731 | −$20Saves prices this year’s tax-rate difference alone. Whole plan, this conversion kept vs dropped: final after-tax estate $2,045 higher in today’s dollars. | — | — |
| 68 | $6.3K | Same tax laterWhy not more this year: Costs about the same tax now as waiting — this conversion is here to shrink future RMDs and move money into tax-free growth, not to save tax this year. | $820Tax on this conversion: Federal (ordinary) $820, Federal capital gains $0. Total $820. | $755 | −$65Saves prices this year’s tax-rate difference alone. Whole plan, this conversion kept vs dropped: final after-tax estate $1,864 higher in today’s dollars. | — | — |
| 69 | $6.5K | Same tax laterWhy not more this year: Costs about the same tax now as waiting — this conversion is here to shrink future RMDs and move money into tax-free growth, not to save tax this year. | $898Tax on this conversion: Federal (ordinary) $898, Federal capital gains $0. Total $898. | $783 | −$115Saves prices this year’s tax-rate difference alone. Whole plan, this conversion kept vs dropped: final after-tax estate $1,697 higher in today’s dollars. | — | — |
| 70 | $20.3K | Same tax laterWhy not more this year: Costs about the same tax now as waiting — this conversion is here to shrink future RMDs and move money into tax-free growth, not to save tax this year. | $2.6KTax on this conversion: Federal (ordinary) $2.6K, Federal capital gains $0. Total $2.6K. | $2.4K | −$211Saves prices this year’s tax-rate difference alone. Whole plan, this conversion kept vs dropped: final after-tax estate $6,884 higher in today’s dollars. | — | — |
| 71 | $19.6K | Same tax laterWhy not more this year: Costs about the same tax now as waiting — this conversion is here to shrink future RMDs and move money into tax-free growth, not to save tax this year. | $2.5KTax on this conversion: Federal (ordinary) $2.5K, Federal capital gains $0. Total $2.5K. | $2.4K | −$143Saves prices this year’s tax-rate difference alone. Whole plan, this conversion kept vs dropped: final after-tax estate $6,469 higher in today’s dollars. | — | — |
| 72 | $19.9K | Same tax laterWhy not more this year: Costs about the same tax now as waiting — this conversion is here to shrink future RMDs and move money into tax-free growth, not to save tax this year. | $2.6KTax on this conversion: Federal (ordinary) $2.6K, Federal capital gains $0. Total $2.6K. | $2.4K | −$195Saves prices this year’s tax-rate difference alone. Whole plan, this conversion kept vs dropped: final after-tax estate $6,247 higher in today’s dollars. | — | — |
| 73 | $19.2K | Same tax laterWhy not more this year: Costs about the same tax now as waiting — this conversion is here to shrink future RMDs and move money into tax-free growth, not to save tax this year. | $2.4KTax on this conversion: Federal (ordinary) $2.4K, Federal capital gains $0. Total $2.4K. | $2.3K | −$136Saves prices this year’s tax-rate difference alone. Whole plan, this conversion kept vs dropped: final after-tax estate $5,887 higher in today’s dollars. | — | — |
| 74 | $19.0K | Same tax laterWhy not more this year: Costs about the same tax now as waiting — this conversion is here to shrink future RMDs and move money into tax-free growth, not to save tax this year. | $2.4KTax on this conversion: Federal (ordinary) $2.4K, Federal capital gains $0. Total $2.4K. | $2.3K | −$133Saves prices this year’s tax-rate difference alone. Whole plan, this conversion kept vs dropped: final after-tax estate $5,601 higher in today’s dollars. | — | — |
| Total | $164.4K | $16.7K | |||||
These reasons describe the schedule the slider is showing.